Here we go again! A
MEME request has arrived from Graham Peacock, author of one of my regular blog reads,
diggingalot, which means it would be rude not to respond! Although, I have to say, I was going to leave this particular debate alone for a while, despite having lots to say on the matter and much more than I will be able to here!
However, this does give me an opportunity, as I have been so warmly invited, to spell out a handful of things that seriously bug me!
Graham's MEME asks for 'Your best contemporary worship song ever' but let's get some things straight first:
- There is NO SUCH THING as Christian Music, CCM or whatever...
- There is NO SUCH THING as Worship Music...
- There is NO SUCH THING as Sacred Music...
- There is NO SUCH THING as Secular Music...
- Music itself is NOT Worship - although music can be worshipful...
- Music IS often Spiritual - more on this in a future post...
- There IS such a thing as a priority to care for the sick, the oppressed, the poor, the downtrodden and the immigrant...
Let's emphasise this with is an important quote in
Rob Bell's book
Velvet Elvis
:
Something can be labeled 'Christian' and not be true or good. It is possible for music to be labeled Christian and be terrible music. Just because it is a Christian book by a Christian author and it was purchased in a Christian bookstore doesn't mean it is all true or good or beautiful. A Christian political group puts me in an awkward position: What if I disagree with them? Am I less of a Christian? What if I am convinced the 'Christian' thing to do is to vote the exact opposite?
'Christian' (the word) is a great noun but a poor adjective.
Another issue with using 'Christian' and 'Worship' as adjectives coupled with the word music has meant that both new commercial opportunities and new genres have arisen over the years. These have led to sub-standard product being peddled to churches and Christians in preference to most mainstream music on the grounds the former is more sanctified. It is not! It is simply not as good as the mainstream equivalent, often a poor quality sound-alike!
I recall
Francis Schaeffer said something along the lines of 'you can have good art with good message, bad art with a good message, good art with a bad message and finally bad art with a bad message'. My opinion (yes, opinion!) is the stuff described as 'Christian Music' and 'Worship Music' falls into the latter category. Why don't we see the image of the Creator in so much of the
mainstream music / art that is there
ready made to utilise in church?
In a service of divine worship music needs to enhance, encourage and engage the congregation. It should not be an opportunity to proselytise, pander to personal preferences or perform for performance's sake. Music must be an integrated element of the liturgy, whatever style the latter follows. Even worse, this type of music is all too often delivered in such an inappropriate, mind numbing, ear bleeding and indecipherable form that still doesn't hide its naffness! Of course, worship does not necessarily take place within a church anyway, it can and, perhaps, should, happen everywhere... that's a debate.
Although I do not think such a thing as 'contemporary worship music' exists I will just mention contemporary hymns. I do concede that songwriter
Stuart Townend has created some moving hymnody, (good art, good message), for example, 'How Deep The Father's Love', which is distinctly different from the usual modern churchy fare.
Having said all that, I have made a suggestion above, simply entitled
'You', which is a song that readily engages me in worship. It is by my buddy
Rob Halligan, singer / songwriter extrordinaire and also the lead singist in
After The Fire. It spells out grandness, it quotes the good book, it employs poetic imagery, it evokes discipleship and even a personal response but not as a simpering request to cuddle up to Jesus. It is just at home in the set list when we play a
full on mainstream concert or in a
liturgical church service, thereby breaking any divide between the sacred and secular.
I know this only just scratches the surface, my plea is to leave the veil of the Temple riven.
PB
comes this unplugged version of their song about love and care, sentiments described in the video by singer